I think that depends on the students, and possibly tackle. But I understand your thoughts here Graene. When I’m training I train 2hrs/day and often 2x2hrs/day, 7 days/week. It’s not uncommon for my students to train 1hr/day and have been doing so before I teach them. But I think it depends to an extent on what they are training and what else they do, as well as why they are training of course.
Overtraining can be an issue. I can think of casters who have gone to the WCs injured. I’d prefer little and often over a lot in one session. I think we learn better that way too. I push people to lighter gear but pre-trip I think they need to train with the gear they will use (and limit training time accordingly).
One thing I don’t want to happen is for them to feel a niggle and continue training. I think we need to resolve that before it becomes an issue.
I don’t think 30mins 3-4 times a week is going to be enough in casting sport for example. I’m not sure it’s enough for CCI. One thing we need to do is work with students during their training to find what works best for them and what their body can cope with. Quite frankly I think everyone in casting sport should be resistance training. This would help avoid injuries. That this doesn’t happen I think reflects where we are with the sport level more than the necessity to train. But I also think that filters down through the ladder to all levels; the more you train/fish/cast the more important it is to exercise outside of flycasting. If you fish 20 times/year and are 25 years old then it’s not so important, but if you fish 200 times/year and are 60 years old then I think it really starts to matter. And if you are retired and fishing every day in your 90s then this is the thing that’s going to allow you to operate.
It might be wrong. Ask me again in 40 years
Cheers, Paul